So after more thought I have decided to revisit expected damage.   Consider the case with a 20/x2 critical, which is reasonably standard.   Probability of Hit (No Critical) ~=  (20-(AC of target - attack of attacker))/20  Minimum is always 1/20, maximum is always 19/20   The probability of a critical hit is always 1/20   Mean Damage = (Max Damage + Min Damage)/2   Expected Total Damage = Prob of Hit * Mean Damage + Prob of Crit  * Mean Damage   In our 20/x2 case:   Expected Total Damage = Mean Damage * (21-(AC-Attack)/20    Consider 3 undead (+3 attack, 2d6+2 damage) attacking an AC 14 PC   Expected Total Damage = (14+4)/2 *(21-(14-3)/20 = 9*10/20 = 4.5   With 3 undead, this means expected damage of 3* 4.5 = 14 damage per round   If we ignore criticals, the answer would be only 12 damage per round, a 17% difference!    Generically we can expand the formula for any critical hit as follows:   Expected Total Damage = Mean Damage *((20+Critical Rolls*(Critical Damage Multipli...
Chronicles of an Elder GM Running, Hacking, and Sharing Advice on TTRPGs